High
Pathogenicity
H5N1 Avian Influenza and
Falconry
Produced by the
NAFA Task Force on Avian
Influenza (March, 2006)
The purpose of this
article is to give
NAFA members information
about avian influenza and inform them of steps
NAFA, in concert with
international falconry organizations is taking.
In late February, 2006,
President Darryl Perkins
appointed a task force to address the issue. The members are:
|
Dr Pat
Redig,
DVM, PhD - Chairman
Patrick Morel -
IAF President /European
Liaison
Mark Williams -
Canadian Liaison
Bill Johnston -
IAF Liaison -
Dr. Bill Ferrier,
DVM -
NAFA/Conservation Committee
Chairman/ DVM -
Alberto
Palleroni , PhD -
Harvard Ecologist -
|
Bob Berry -
NARBA President / Breeder
Cal
Sandfort - Peregrine
Fund Breeding Specialist
Victor
Hardaswick -
Biologist / Breeder
Dr. Bill Cornatzer
, MD - Physician
Roger Johnson - Quail Breeder
|
*Frank
Bond - NAFA General
Counsel
*Darryl A.
Perkins - NAFA President
The charge given by
President Perkins was to "gather all the pertinent information
and make recommendations for the best course of action."
Overview of the current situation:
Birds, especially
waterfowl, are the natural host of Type A Influenza viruses
(there are types A, B, & C). Types B and C are not part of the
present concern. There are 144 major types of influenza A
viruses and wild birds, especially waterfowl, are the natural
host for all of them. Ordinarily, no disease is caused in the
natural host.
The Type A influenza
viruses are identified by a pair of proteins on the external
surface of their capsule, the
hemagluttinins and
neuraminidases. There are sixteen known types of
hemagluttinins (H) and 9
types of neuraminidases (N),
giving 144 different combinations of H's and N's. For examples,
H3N2 is a common influenza
virus found in poultry, swine and humans in the U. S. The
Spanish Flu epidemic of 1918 was caused by an
H1N1 virus, that is still
present among us, but most everyone is immune to it so it causes
no disease. The current concern is with the
H5N1 Virus with
hemagluttinin types
H5,
H7, and
H9 are the forms that have
shown the greatest capacity to pass from birds to humans and to
develop into strains capable of causing severe disease - i.e.
high pathogenicity strains.
Most of the time, Type A
viruses circulate in their bird hosts, waterfowl and aquatic
shore birds, as low
pathogenic forms - that is they pass from duck to duck and cause
no disease. If a low path form is introduced into a novel host,
such as a turkey or a chicken, it most often causes mild disease
characterized by depression, runny noses and in a flock of
layers, a decrease in egg production. In fact, in poultry
influenza is known as "egg drop" syndrome.
In a few cases, when the
virus is introduced into a new host and is passing from bird to
bird, becoming more adapted to that host as it does, it may
randomly evolve into a high
pathogenic form and cause severe disease and death. This is
apparently what happened in the early 1990's in China when the
current H5N1, formerly a low
pathogenic virus in waterfowl, became introduced into domestic
chickens. It appears that it circulated in the live bird
markets and small poultry operations for possibly several years
before it changed into a high path form probably around 1995 or
1996. In the process of making that change, it also developed
the capacity to pass from bird to human and cause disease in
them also.
In a strange twist of
fate, this high pathogenic (HP) H5N1
was reintroduced into wild waterfowl in northwestern China in
the spring of 2005, causing a die-off in roughly 1,500 or so
bar-headed geese (Anser
indicus) at
Qinghai lake in Western
China (Nature vol 436: 191
July 2005). At the same time it was spreading rapidly
throughout eastern China, Viet Nam,
Cambodia and Laos, causing death in thousands of chickens, some
domestic ducks and several dozen people. Attempts to contain
the virus resulted in the mass culling of millions of chickens.
In the fall of 2005, the virus was seen spreading westward along
the border of southern Russian states with
Kazakhstan and by the first
of the year, it was as far west as the Danube River delta in
Romania. In January 2006 it popped up in domestic turkeys in
Turkey and in February, it inexplicably appeared in chickens in
the African nation of Nigeria. Also, there was an isolated
incident in Saudi Arabia wherein a Saker falcon in a veterinary
hospital died of H5N1 and
several others in contact were
euthanized, resulting in the loss of 37 falcons. The most
westward human deaths were those of three family members in
Turkey. In late February, several dead mute swans were found in
various places in Europe, setting off mass culls of domestic
poultry in a so-called 1 kilometer cull zone around any area
where a bird with confirmed H5N1
virus was found. By the end of February,
H5N1 was in Germany, France,
Italy, Poland, and the Balkan states. Though reactions vary
from country to country, in most places it has been required
that all outdoor poultry be brought under cover and import/
export restrictions were placed on poultry and other birds. It
remains to be seen what the duration of any of these limitations
will be and that won't be known until more is known about this
virus.
From the early westward
movements of the virus out of China, migratory birds were
incriminated as a vehicle.
However, the movement of the virus has been in more of an
east-west direction than one following the known migratory bird
pathways. Further the movement was occurring at a time of year
when migratory birds were not. It is possible that regional
movements of some carrier species, such as the mute swan or the
migratory whooper swan could account for some of the
introductions. However, the distances that the virus traveled
were vast, and except for swans, there were no mass die-offs of
waterfowl being reported anywhere (One opinion on this pattern
of events suggested that swans were being affected because as
grazers, they may be feeding
on manure from commercial poultry operations spread on farm
fields, and in so doing, become exposed to the virus).
Additionally, most outbreaks in widely separated areas
repeatedly turned up in poultry, begging the question as to what
role movements of poultry in commercial trade and the exchange
of fighting cocks were playing in the spread.
HP
H5N1 Influenza in North America
It is regarded as
inevitable at this point that HP
H5N1 will arrive in
North America. When and where will depend on the route of
introduction. If by migratory birds, it is believed that
species such as tundra swans, pintail ducks, and
sandhill cranes, among 26
species of birds known to cross over from North America into
Siberia, could introduce it into Alaska. From there it could
spread through any of the flyways
and be distributed throughout the continent. On the other hand,
given the trade, some of it illegal, in
uncooked poultry products
that occurs between the U.S. and SE Asia, as well as birds of
various types in unregulated live
bird markets, it could just as well be introduced through trade
routes. Within the next few months and
continuing indefinitely, a
great deal of surveillance in wild birds and in live bird
markets will be implemented, some of it ongoing already for
several years, to attempt to detect the introduction of the
virus. The USDA and USFWS
will expend $7.4 million in Alaska in 2006 alone for
surveillance. Despite all of this surveillance aimed at
detecting introduction, it is most likely that detection will
occur as a consequence of a die-off of waterfowl someplace.
Either way, information networks are in place and it will be
known almost immediately.
A high-tech
recombinant vaccine for birds
against avian flu, that is under development by Fort Dodge, is
scheduled for testing in zoo collections in the near future.
This work is being coordinated by the Association of Zoos and
Aquaria. We will keep abreast of progress in this work as well
as any other vaccine developments and pass this information to
the falconry community as it becomes available.
Falconers and HP
H5N1
Despite the uncertainties
of where and when the virus will show up, it is important for
falconers to prepare for the
day that it does. This preparation needs to necessarily include
an understanding of the risks posed to one's birds, both direct
and indirect. Risk of infection occurs in exposure from
captured prey, from food sources, and from contamination. The
virus is very hardy and travels well on vehicles, clothing and
utensils. Biosecurity as it
applies to falconry will have
to be defined, and matters such as taking and handling of prey
likely to be infected, quarantining falcons that have
taken species at risk of carrying HP
H5N1, protection of quail supplies from infection, the
possibility of vaccination of
raptors (currently, there is no specific vaccine for HP
H5N1 - where vaccines are
being used in poultry, it is controversial and typically
utilizes one made for use against
H5N2, a close relative.
However the vaccine has not been tested for efficacy against HP
H5N1 and there is a very real
risk that it will allow the virus to circulate undetected at a
subclinical level), limiting
visitors and using disinfectants
and foot baths will have to
be considered. The indirect risks are largely associated with
the response of regulatory officialdom. There are ongoing
discussions between them and entities such as zoos and outdoor
range-rearing poultry operations to establish guidelines for the
response. We will be informed of these as material valuable to
us will be contained in those discussions. We will seek to
provide a basis of understanding with regulatory agencies that
would provide protection for the
raptors of falconers
seen to be operating in a "best practices" manner, which will
have to be defined. The major concern is
indiscriminate culling.
Currently, a 1 km cull zone is established around any site of an
outbreak in poultry and all birds in that zone may be targeted.
The third risk lies in the public and media response that arises
from a confirmed detection of the virus and the collateral
damage that may arise from that, a facet which may lie outside
our scope.
These and many other
related issues will be thoroughly investigated by this task
force. Information and recommendations will be formulated and
passed to the falconry community. In the meantime, it is
important to remember that the focus is on the HP
H5N1 influenza virus only.
There are many other influenza types around and anyone
who has been duck hawking has
been exposing themselves and their birds to these viruses for as
long as they've been hawking, including low path
H5N1. Until HP H5N1 shows
up, nothing has changed. When it does, everything will be
impacted.
As the task force engages
in its work, information will be passed to
falconers in the manner most
appropriate for the circumstances. This will include direct
broadcast e-mail messages as well as information posted on the
NAFA web-site. There are
several up-to-the-minute sources of information that falconers
can access on the internet to
stay abreast of the most current information about the
occurrence of H5N1 and some
of the responses to its activity. They are listed as follows:
Additional
Resources
Recombinomics- One of the largest, fastest, most-up-to
date sites on the net for developments related to H5N1
http://www.pandemicflu.gov/
- One stop access
to U.S. Government avian and pandemic flu information. Managed
by the Department of Health and Human Services.
http://www.aphis.usda.gov/vs/npip/
- web site for national poultry improvement plan - gives
information about biosecurity
for avian species and provides a registry of poultry producers
that are registered in this plan.
Promed (subscribe at:
majordomo@promedmail.org)
- this site provides updates, multiple times daily, on the
latest reports regarding avian influenza and many other diseases
of human and animal concern.
World Animal Health
Organization (OIE -
http://www.oie.int/eng/en_index.htm).
Provides up-to-date information on animal diseases on a regular
basis. A good source of information on meetings, information
exchanges, and policy development for combating animal
diseases. Much information about HP
H5N1.
*The
NAFA President and General
Counsel are de facto members of all
NAFA committees.